| Platinum | Eggbar |
| Gold | Dearborn Coney Island |
| Silver | Rex's Golden Grill |
| Bronze | Glass Onion Griddle |
| Top Pick | Big Boy |
| Top Pick | Brazen Bagels |
| Top Pick | Einstein Bros. Bagels |
| Top Pick | Holiday Grill |
| Top Pick | Red Olive Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Brooklyn Street Local |