| Platinum | Mi Cookie Project |
| Gold | Iced Cookie Creations by Bobbi |
| Silver | Capri Italian Bakery |
| Bronze | Lebon Sweets |
| Top Pick | Iversen's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Layal's Gourmet Sweets |
| Top Pick | Mrs. Fields Cookies |
| Top Pick | River Q Bakery in Trenton |
| Top Pick | Yogurtopia |