| Platinum | Bartz Bakery |
| Gold | Einstein Bros. Bagels |
| Silver | Dearborn Italian Bakery |
| Bronze | Iversen's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Auntie Anne's |
| Top Pick | Capri Italian Bakery |
| Top Pick | Donutville USA |
| Top Pick | Jack's Italian Bakery |
| Top Pick | Monroe Bakery |
| Top Pick | West Village Bakery |